Strength Training Over 40: Your Mind Is the Limiting Factor

JT

Jan. 28, 2026

Strength Training Over 40: Your Mind Is the Limiting Factor 

By Jerry Teixeira | Nearly 30 Years of Strength Experience


Jerry Teixeira with gold medal at first BJJ competition at 45 – bodyweight strength training results

Me and my wife after my first BJJ comp at 45 years old. 

Your Biggest Advantage Isn't Your Program

Most New Year's resolutions are dead by February.


Gym memberships collect dust. Diets collapse. The "new you" quietly becomes the same you.

Why?


It's not the plan. It's the belief behind it.

 

The Placebo Effect Works in the Gym Too

When you genuinely believe a program will work, your body responds.


Studies show placebo effects reduce pain, improve mood, and enhance performance—not through magic, but through expectation. Your brain is listening to what you tell it.


Tell it this program probably won't work for someone your age? It'll make sure you're right.


Tell it you're the kind of person who can't stay consistent? It'll prove that too.


This is the nocebo effect—the dark side of the same coin. Negative expectations create negative outcomes. Doubt your recovery, expect to feel broken, assume you'll quit by week three—and you will.


Belief Becomes Identity. Identity Becomes Action.

If you believe you're inconsistent, you'll stay inconsistent.

One missed workout becomes permission to miss the next one. Your mind was already looking for the exit.


But flip that script—decide you're someone who shows up—and suddenly one missed day is just a day. Not a pattern. Not proof of failure. Just a blip.


The people who succeed long-term with at-home calisthenics or any training style aren't more disciplined than you. They just stopped negotiating with themselves.


Case in Point

At 45, I signed up for my first BJJ competition. Zero experience competing. Plenty of reasons to doubt myself.

But I didn't. I trained. I prepared. And I believed—fully—that I was capable.


Took gold.


Not because I was the most talented guy on the mat. Because I had built functional strength and integrated power through nearly 30 years of training—and I didn't give my brain an out.


That's what real strength and conditioning comes down to. Not just the physical. The mental.


The Bottom Line

I can give you the best program in the world. The perfect Minimum Effective Dose—the sustainable approach that delivers results without burnout or grinding your joints into dust.


None of it works if you don't believe you can do it.


So before you tweak your macros or optimize your training split, ask yourself a harder question:

Do you actually believe this will work for you?


If the answer is no—or even "maybe"—that's the first thing to fix. Not the program. The belief.

Decide you're someone who follows through. Then watch your actions fall in line.


That's the real secret to joint longevity, sustainable strength training, and a body that still performs at 50, 60, and beyond. Not the perfect plan. The belief that you're the kind of person who executes it.


Stay capable,

JT


Jerry Teixeira has been training for nearly 30 years and coaching clients since 2019. He won gold at his first BJJ competition at 45 and trains in his backyard in California.


FAQ: The Psychology of Strength Over 40

Does "Mindset" really change physical results in strength training??

Yes. Research on the nocebo effect shows that if you expect a program to fail, or believe you're "too old" for bodyweight strength training, your nervous system can actually limit force production and recovery. I've seen it over nearly 30 years of training: the people who believe they can adapt, do. The ones who don't, struggle—regardless of the program.

How do I stop talking myself out of workouts when I'm tired?

Lower the barrier. This is where the Minimum Effective Dose works as a mental tool, not just a physical one. Committing to a focused 30-minute session in your garage is a lot easier to show up for than a 90-minute gym grind. When the ask is small, you stop negotiating with yourself. 

Can I actually change my identity after years of being inconsistent?

Yes. Identity is built through small wins, stacked over time. When I started BJJ at 44, I had to adopt a beginner's mindset after decades of being competent in calisthenics. Showing up 2-3 times a week gave my brain the proof it needed to stop seeing me as "the old guy trying something new" and start seeing me as a practitioner. Same principle applies to you.

Is this approach suitable for beginners?

It's essential for beginners. Most people quit because they expect perfection—one missed day becomes total failure. The MED approach meets you where you are. Small wins build belief. Belief builds consistency. Consistency builds results.

First Name:

Email:

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published